Moderation policy
How submitted attempts are reviewed, reported, and removed. Last updated 2026-07-11.
Tier 1 — automatic filter
- Length: minimum 20, maximum 3,000 characters.
- Link count: up to 3 external URLs per attempt.
- Blocked patterns: common spam keywords (gambling, illegal services, crypto airdrops, etc.) are blocked at the server.
Failed submissions return a 400 with a clear message; no record is persisted.
Tier 2 — curator review
A small team (initially: the maintainers) reviews high-signal attempts and may grant a *curator pick* badge. Criteria:
- genuine engagement with the problem (small-case experiments, partial reductions, novel framings),
- precise statements; KaTeX renders cleanly; assumptions named,
- links and references are *additive* — not a wall of URLs in place of content.
Curator picks bubble to the top of the per-problem list and feed the *Best attempt of the week* daily card.
Removal criteria
Submissions may be removed (with notification when possible) for:
- verifiable spam, phishing, or illegal content,
- harassment, doxxing, or targeted attacks against another user,
- plagiarism (copy-paste from textbooks/Wikipedia without attribution),
- duplicate submissions by the same user on the same problem.
Authors may always delete their own attempts.
Community reporting and editing
- Reporting: any visitor with a browser identifier can report an attempt once. Three distinct reports automatically hide it pending review.
- Editing: attempts are immutable once submitted. To revise, delete and resubmit.
- Threaded replies: attempts are flat — no nested replies. Quote in your own attempt instead.
Timeline
- Auto-filter: immediate (server-side).
- Curator review: public notebooks and visible attempts enter a seven-day review SLA. A review may end without a curator pick.
- Auto-hidden review: an operator records restore or keep-hidden within 24 hours of automatic hiding.
- Removal appeals: within 30 days; otherwise the decision stands.
Questions or feedback? Open an issue at github.com/forty4/math-voyage.