Perspective voyage · 1984
If a better policy would have meant that this person never existed, can the present policy be said to make that person worse off?
This is an editorial route for the viewer. Similar ideas are not presented as direct influence or a single line of progress.
The question that moves this idea
Instead of memorizing a conclusion, follow the evidence scenes to see what this perspective distinguishes and where its explanation stops.
The nonidentity problem arises when different long-term policies cause different people to exist, frustrating a purely person-affecting account of harm as making someone worse off than otherwise.
This sentence is an editorial paraphrase linked to the listed sources, not a direct quotation.
The Nonidentity Problem
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Locator: §1 The Problem; policy and future-person cases
Open sourceTime × place
We do not invent a birthplace for an idea. Only evidence-backed events such as writing, publication, teaching, and reception appear here.
1984 CE · 1984
Keep the voyage moving
Compare this perspective with three others on the same cases.
Enter the judgment sceneRestore the period, works, and places behind the single claim.
Open the person’s full voyageRead the claim inside its argument and publication or reception history.
Return to the work